Across every budget, all-inclusive resorts are some of the top choices for travelers planning a trip to Mexico or the Caribbean. Why? Because they’re zero hassle. But they’re not automatically right for you—or for the type of vacation you want this time.
Your goal: keep the kids happy
Got the kiddos along? All-inclusives can be a sanity saver for parents and grandparents because when kids are hungry, they want to eat now. (Honestly, I’m the same way.) While you’ll have sit-down options at all-inclusives, there’s typically a buffet available, too, where kids can grab what they want when they want it. Most all-ages resorts also have kids’ clubs with trained staff and surprisingly good offerings to keep them entertained if you—I mean they—need a break.
Verdict: All-inclusive
Your goal: no stress
You can turn your brain off at all-inclusives. More and more of them use a bracelet as a room key, so you don’t even have to remember to stick one in your pocket on your way out the door! They’re designed for people who want to spend most of their time relaxing with a drink in their hands. There’s always something to do on property—the gym, tennis courts, poolside activities, and even off-property excursions you can book—but you’ll get the most bang for your buck if you’re looking for long days and nights of blissful relaxation.
Verdict: all-inclusive
Your goal: exquisite cuisine
All-inclusives get a bad rap for their food. And yes, sometimes it’s deserved, especially at the lower-budget properties. But most of them have stepped up their food game in recent years, with buffets that include things like sushi and a la carte restaurants with great seafood and steaks. That being said, they’re not the right fit for true foodies who seek out Michelin-starred experiences. These properties simply won’t meet your expectations.
Verdict: no all-inclusive
Your goal: drink margaritas until you float
If you’re looking for an excuse to say “yes” to that third (or thirteenth drink), all-inclusives give it to you. This might seem like a no-brainer, but all-inclusives aren’t a great bargain for teetotalers and those who eat very lightly. On the other hand, my family is vegetarian/vegan, my kids don’t drink much (one isn’t of age), and we still enjoy all-inclusives for the ease of the experience.
Verdict: all-inclusive
Your goal: cultural immersion
All-inclusives offer excursions—some of which may include activities like rainforest ziplining or exploring Mayan ruins. But true culture vultures won’t get the deeply connected tours and experiences of authentically local engagement.
Verdict: no all-inclusive
Your goal: romance, baby!
Some of this depends on your personality; if you can’t sit still even on vacation, maybe try a different kind of accommodation. But for the most part, all-inclusives are designed for romance seekers. The rooms and suites tend to be large and well equipped, room service is almost always included, and it’s easy to find tables for two at the restaurants. But I’m begging you, please book an adults-only resort. A screaming baby at the next table (or in the next room) is a mood killer.
Verdict: maybe all-inclusive
The options are nearly endless, and our mission at Blue Cobblestone Travel is to find the perfect fit for clients—whether that means an all-inclusive, beachside bungalow, boutique hotel, eco lodge, B&B, villa, and more!


